PGR BLOG
Blog Pages
Archives
Categories
 
PRIMARY GLOBAL RESEARCH BLOG
Archive for the ‘Lloyd Walmsley’ Category

Ad Markets Strong in 1Q and Trend Continue to Improve in 2Q

Lloyd Walmsley
Wednesday, May 5th, 2010

PGR’s experts in traditional media ad buying saw strong 1Q result. Experts estimate an aggregate 5-10% growth in 1Q ad budgets and expect additional acceleration into 2Q. An increase in political advertising has fueled the acceleration of TV advertising and outdoor advertisers are hopeful that a new rating currency will boost their sales, but radio advertising continues to suffer from dwindling spending.

TV Recovery in Full Steam: Experts report tighter TV inventory and fewer cancellations and CPM increases in 1Q in both broadcast and cable TV advertising. Since auto advertisers roared back into the market late last year, ad buyers have reported broadcast and cable TV networks are demanding higher prices and offering less flexibility. Experts note scatter pricing is up between 8-40% over the upfront, depending on the network.  Experts look for higher upfront and scatter market prices this Fall. Fierce political elections also bode well for political spending, which is already adding inventory constraints to the networks. Among specific networks, experts see strength in broadcast networks CBS, ABC (DIS) and Fox (NWS) and cable networks TNT (TWX), USA (CMCSA) and Discovery (DISCA). Given the TV ad market’s notable weakness in 2009, expert reports point to strong year-over-year revenue growth in TV in 1Q and 2010, especially in broadcast given easier comparisons. National CineMedia (NCMI) may be best positioned to capture the tight TV scatter market given it sells less inventory on a forward basis than TV networks and some of its forward-sold inventory of automatic CPM inflators cushioning the company from last year’s market woes.

Political Advertising Heating Up: Ad buyers report political dollars flowing into advertising, starting to put pressure on inventory and support prices. Most experts see this situation intensifying with the approach of fall elections and following the Supreme Court decision to lift corporate spending limits on political campaigns. This is likely to benefit local broadcast TV in particular (CBS, DIS, GCI).

Outdoor Improving Slowly but Lagging: The tone from billboard advertisers was less enthusiastic than that of TV or Internet ad buyers, with some Outdoor experts reporting an improvement in the market while others noted ongoing weakness. Outdoor is likely to be a later cycle recovery than other media. Expert reports on the new EYES ON rating system rolling out this year suggest outdoor could address broader ad budgets and see new growth in 2011 and beyond. That said, the new rating system is unlikely to be fully rolled out until the end of 2010 at earliest and may be susceptible to delays in full implementation. (See the Network View on EYES ON for further color).

Radio Continues to Languish: Experts report that radio spending has continued to drop. The lower PPM ratings have led radio companies to increase their spot loads and require ad buyers to purchase more inventory to hit the same campaign goals. As a result, buyers seem less inclined to spend in radio.

[Post to Twitter] Tweet This Post   

Eyes On Outdoor Advertising

Lloyd Walmsley
Wednesday, April 21st, 2010

 

Experts are optimistic that Eyes On, the billboard advertising industry’s new rating system, will draw dollars into outdoor advertising but the impact will not be apparent until 2011 or beyond. The Eyes On rollout is moving slowly but it will soon replace the current standard of DEC numbers. We queried our network of outdoor advertising experts to better understand how the new ratings system could drive more dollars to the medium.

 

Eyes On versus DEC: Eyes On is used by some outdoor companies alongside the historical Daily Effective Circulation (DEC) measurement system. DEC ratings multiply traffic data by an estimate of people per car to measure the “opportunity to see” a billboard. Eyes On supplements traffic count and regional demographics with discounts for view obstructions, road type, and ad proximity, size, and angle to measure those “likely to see” a billboard. Eyes On provides a more reliable measure of audience and an improved level of demographic targeting that can be compared to other forms of broadcast media, including TV and radio.

 

Attract Ad Dollars: PGR experts on the Outdoor Advertising sell-side are cautiously optimistic that Eyes On can tap into new ad budgets that previously spent little on Outdoor due to its relatively unsophisticated measurement system. More dollars stand to be allocated to Outdoor with this deeper integration into the media budget process. After all, Outdoor still compares favorably to TV and radio on a cost per mille basis in key demos. This increasing drive for efficiency and metric driven advertising could lead Eyes On to favor Outdoor.

 

Expect Lower Ratings: Eyes On ratings, because of the discounts, tend to run approximately 30% lower than DEC ratings and experts note the lower ratings are exacerbated on highway billboards further from the road. While the Outdoor advertising sales process is not done strictly on ratings, one wonders if more accurate ratings could lead to budget shifts away from higher priced boards.

 

Limited Market Impact: Clear Channel Outdoor is the only company, according to experts, currently using Eyes On.  Some experts have yet to see Eyes On ratings in the market at all. Mom and pops and smaller regional players are likely to be slow to make the transition.

 

Stronger Outdoor Market: Experts indicate the Outdoor market has begun to see the impact of an improving economy. However enthusiasm in the Outdoor space appears muted, especially when compared to excitement for a rebound in online advertising (display and search) as well in TV advertising - PGR experts report strong 1Q trends and further tightening of inventory and rising prices into 2Q. Outdoor is improving but appears to be lagging other advertising.

[Post to Twitter] Tweet This Post   

Search for Advertising Dollars

Lloyd Walmsley
Tuesday, April 20th, 2010

PGR experts in online advertising report strong growth in 1Q and signs of further improvement in 2Q. While marketers report clear growth in ad budgets, they note that clients continue to show signs of hesitancy with short notice on requests for proposals, heavy reliance on the spot market and a vigilant focus on ROI and metric-driven forms of advertising.

Experts indicate that search advertising is leading the way out of the recession, and Google continues to hold/gain share of search spending.  SEMs expressed a positive reception to Yahoo’s new network distribution tool and some shift in budgets away from Yahoo affiliate sights towards Yahoo O&O sites, a clear positive from a margin perspective.  That said, no marketers report spending more ad dollars on Yahoo Search in aggregate. Furthermore, many experts postulate Bing will continue to seize search advertising market share and the prevalence of this view could impact how marketers are inclined to allocate search dollars.

In online display advertising, PGR experts report a firming marketplace, higher prices, and increasing interest in tight integration of ad units with premium content sites. Experts are upbeat on the Google display product over the long-term, but there is a mixed reaction at AOL as some experts note continuing unrest among sales representatives, which may reflect the ongoing challenges within the business.

But change is ahead.  Increased smartphone penetration and media consumption from industry leaders Quattro (AAPL), AdMob (GOOG) and JumpTap is driving experts to predict increased investments in mobile advertising for the year ahead.

[Post to Twitter] Tweet This Post   

Car Spots Make Ad Slots Cost Lots

Lloyd Walmsley
Tuesday, March 16th, 2010

A rebound in TV advertising revenue that started in September of 2009 continues to gain steam in 1Q and is likely to carry forward into 2Q, according to media buyers in PGR’s Network. Much of the momentum stems from a reinvigorated automotive sector whose new-car ads are snapping up enough time to squeeze ad inventory, touching off substantial price spikes in scatter TV ad prices.  Experts note across-the-board pricing gains in broadcast and cable at local and national levels. Those in the direct response space have seen lower clearance levels in spite of attempts by some DR advertisers to test clearance by pushing pricing higher. Low clearance levels suggest strong demand and in all likelihood, higher floor pricing. Our Network singles out Time Warner’s Turner network and NBC Universal’s USA and MSNBC networks as particularly strong, although most experts agree the rising tide will lift all boats and impact a variety of players in the TV ad market.

[Post to Twitter] Tweet This Post   

GOOG Out of China? BIDU Will Benefit Most

Lloyd Walmsley
Wednesday, January 27th, 2010

PGR’s network believes BIDU has the most to gain should GOOG pull out of China. However, others stand to gain as well including MSFT’s Bing, SOHU’s Sogo, Alibaba, SINA, and SOHU albeit to a far lesser extent. Why? Well, GOOG was very good at monetizing traffic, thus its revenue pie would not likely transition altogether to other players who monetize less effectively.

Experts note that BIDU’s Phoenix Nest continues to weigh on ad spending at the site in the near term as improving click-throughs give advertisers the same results for less, reducing ad spending. Longer term, marketers believe BIDU’s improved performance will attract more dollars by providing more qualified leads and higher conversions.

Of course GOOG hasn’t quit China yet and at least one network expert suggested China’s government may quietly accede to uncensored search results. The rationale being that information on Google.cn is less threatening than what could potentially occur in web 2.0, which is where censorship is focused today.

Referencing spending plans, PGR’s network sees strong growth in Chinese and global online advertising in 2010. Experts also note increased experimentation with advertising on Chinese social-networking and video sites, where usage is growing strongly.

[Post to Twitter] Tweet This Post